Our Menu
Cakes and Pies
Savage's irresistible pies are crafted with our signature homemade pie dough, known for its perfect balance of flakiness and buttery richness. Each pie is generously filled with your choice of delightful fillings. A beloved local specialty, our Pecan Pie, is a holiday season essential!
Cookies
Indulge in the timeless classic that has made Savage's famous: our traditional gingerbread man cookie. Available in tiny and large sizes, each cookie embodies the perfect harmony of sugar and spice. This timeless treat promises a memorable experience in every bite.
Unlike the ordinary sugar cookie , our recipe crafts a dough using real butter, ensuring a rich and indulgent flavor. As it bakes, this special dough delicately spreads, creating a luscious sugary crust atop each cookie. Prepare to be enchanted by the perfect balance of buttery goodness and sugary bliss in every bite.
Our iced cookies are an all-butter cookie and are without a doubt our most popular cookie!
Our iced cookies are an all-butter cookie and are without a doubt our most popular cookie!
Our iced cookies are an all-butter cookie and are without a doubt our most popular cookie!
Our iced cookies are an all-butter cookie and are without a doubt our most popular cookie!
Our iced cookies are an all-butter cookie and are without a doubt our most popular cookie!
Our iced cookies are an all-butter cookie and are without a doubt our most popular cookie!
Our iced cookies are an all-butter cookie and are without a doubt our most popular cookie!
Our iced cookies are an all-butter cookie and are without a doubt our most popular cookie!
Our iced cookies are an all-butter cookie and are without a doubt our most popular cookie!
Our iced cookies are an all-butter cookie and are without a doubt our most popular cookie!
Our iced cookies are an all-butter cookie and are without a doubt our most popular cookie!
Our iced cookies are an all-butter cookie and are without a doubt our most popular cookie!
$ varies
Desserts
Introducing Savage's classic fudge brownie—a rich delight with chopped pecans and a luscious layer of chocolate icing. Perfectly hand-cut into bite-sized portions, ideal for teas and receptions.
$26.95-half | $44.00-whole
Biscuits 16/pan
Our famous Tiny Cheese Biscuits are a local favorite bursting with flavor! Made with the finest New York Sharp Cheddar Cheese, buttermilk, and real butter, these biscuits are a true delight for the taste buds. Crafted with care, the dough rises twice to ensure a light and fluffy texture. Baked in an oven-safe pan with 16 delicious biscuits, they're perfect for all occasions.
Our Large Rosemary Biscuits are sold by the half dozen. These are a larger version of our famous Tiny Rosemary Biscuits! These delectable biscuits start with the same cherished roll dough as our Tiny Plain Biscuits, but are adorned with fragrant rosemary for an extra punch of flavor. Perfectly paired with dishes like Roast Beef and Swiss or Beef Tenderloin, they're an exquisite addition to any party or reception. Half dozen
Our Tiny Plain Biscuits are a delightful rendition of a classic favorite! Crafted from our signature roll dough, these bite-sized wonders boast the unique flavor of our renowned rolls. With two layers of hand-prepared dough, they're perfect for creating your ideal bite-sized sandwich. Baked in an oven-safe pan with 16 biscuits, they're a versatile treat for any occasion.
Coffeecakes
Savor the irresistible flavors of our coffeecakes, crafted to perfection in convenient 8" x 8" square foil pans. Each cake generously serves 8, making them an ideal choice for sharing during casual breakfast gatherings or adding a touch of sweetness to any celebration. With a variety of flavors to choose from, these coffeecakes are sure to be the star of your next get-together, promising a mouthwatering experience with every slice.
Breads & Buns
A departure from traditional bread, our Italian Bread Sticks are a culinary delight in their own right. Each stick is meticulously hand-rolled to achieve the perfect thinness, crisping ever so slightly upon baking. Brushed with melted butter and sprinkled with salt, they offer a savory and flavorful experience that is simply irresistible. Sold only by the dozen.
Our Hot Dog Buns are available for purchase by the dozen. Crafted from the same distinctive dough as our other buns, these homemade hot dog buns will astound you with the difference they make at your next cookout!
Experience the freshness of our homemade loaf bread selection, including classic Homemade White, hearty Whole Wheat, and flavorful Rye. Baked daily from scratch, each loaf promises exceptional taste and quality. With approximately 20 slices per loaf, it's perfect for any meal or snack.
Experience the freshness of our homemade loaf bread selection, including classic Homemade White, hearty Whole Wheat, and flavorful Rye. Baked daily from scratch, each loaf promises exceptional taste and quality. With approximately 20 slices per loaf, it's perfect for any meal or snack.
Pastries
Experience the irresistible charm of our classic Danish pastry! Created with care, our renowned recipe involves rolling Danish pastry in real butter between layers of sweet dough, yielding a pastry that is luxuriously rich and exquisitely flaky. With a variety of luscious fruit fillings available, there's a delightful option to satisfy every taste preference.
A divine Danish pastry infused with the richness of almond paste. Each bite offers a heavenly experience, with a flakiness and richness that surpasses ordinary pastries. Uniquely delicious and utterly irresistible, our bear claws are a true indulgence for pastry lovers everywhere.
These are our most popular breakfast sweet rolls! They are made from sweet dough rolled into a log with special fillings designed to enhance the moistness and flavor. Each sweet roll is topped with streusel after being placed in a cupcake frame. We offer a variety of fillings to choose from! Our Meltaways are sold by the half dozen and dozen online.
A bite-sized delight perfect for breakfast or brunch. Crafted with tender sweet dough and filled with tangy orange marmalade, each roll bursts with citrusy flavor. To elevate the orange experience, we drizzle them with a luscious icing made from fresh orange juice, adding a sweet and zesty finish that will leave your taste buds tingling with delight.
Our Cheese Pockets are crafted by enveloping Danish pastry in layers of real butter and sweet dough, resulting in a pastry that is richer and flakier than the rest. Each pocket is filled with creamy cream cheese, creating a delicious treat that has become a beloved favorite among our customers.
Pies
Cupcakes
Perfect for any occasion, our cupcakes come in a variety of cake and icing flavors.
Cakes
$ varies
$65 | $85
$65 | $95
$45 | $90